Dayton ‘settled, cracked, and broke’ in many places. How was lawsuit settled?

Aerial black-and-white view of a grain elevator with cylindrical storage silos, railway tracks, warehouses, and surrounding town.

Sometimes, a concrete elevator didn’t work out for the farmers’ cooperative that commissioned it or the construction company that built it.

Take, for example, the gleaming new elevator, seen above, in the village Dayton, Iowa.

Although we can’t find it in the records of Tillotson Construction Co., we know it was built in 1954.

Not long afterward, Farmers’ Elevator Guide (v. 48-50, 1953-55 p. 61) carried this news:

Dayton—Farmers Elevator Company has filed suit in federal court at Fort Dodge, Iowa, asking $92,120 from Tillotson Construction Co., Omaha, Neb.

The cooperative also is seeking a court order for the removal by the construction firm of a new 150,000-bushel elevator at Dayton. An alternate request included in the petition asks that if the court does not grant the damages and order the structure removed, that it should determine amount needed to place elevator in condition to conform with the contract between the companies and to grant that amount to the Dayton cooperative.

The petition charges that “due to faulty plans and construction the elevator is unsafe for use and in dangerous condition and is liable at any time to collapse.” The elevator was completed in September 1954 and less than a month later “settled, cracked and broke in numerous places,” the Dayton company alleges in the petition.

At the time the elevator was found to be damaged it was loaded with 110,000 bushels of corn and 30,000 bushels of beans.

Newspaper clipping headlined “Flood Aid Asked for 19 Counties After Air Survey,” reporting Iowa flood disaster assistance.

By 1954, Tillotson Construction had built a couple hundred elevators or so. The process was tried and true. So what caused the problems in Dayton? It is known that Webster County had some tricky soils. Maybe it was this factor in combination with the heavy rains in June of that year. We find a summary of the flooding via a web search:

“Just prior to July, Fort Dodge [twenty miles north] and the [nearby] Des Moines River valley experienced historic, destructive flooding in June 1954, shifting into a hot and dry mid-summer climate.”

A Unites States Geological Survey report delivered this analysis:

“Rainfall during the latter part of May and the first half of June 1954, culminating in a series of heavy rains June 15-22, caused streams in north-central and northwest Iowa to rise to record heights. The floods of June 1954 were the greatest known on the Des Moines River below Fort Dodge to Des Moines.”

We visited Dayton in 2014 and found the Tillotson elevator in fighting trim.

Although we can find nothing on the resolution of the lawsuit, more information may present itself. Meantime, we consider the reminder that even after the builder’s many successes, each job had its risks, and misreading them was always a possibility.

2 comments on “Dayton ‘settled, cracked, and broke’ in many places. How was lawsuit settled?”

  1. Chandler Thomas's avatar Chandler Thomas says:

    Slip formed structures like grain elevators are particularly rigid and monolithic. Most grain elevators settle when they are first loaded. In-fact, most builders provided operators with instructions for initial loading to help ensure that there was uniform settlement, not differential settlement. Typically the initial loading instructions were simple, directing the operator to keep the grain level in all bins within 10 feet of each other until the facility was initially loaded. There are some well documented instances of elevators suffering significant differential settlement resulting in a pronounced lean and in the case of an elevator in ND, complete soil failure with the structure falling over in its side. In those instances where a structure suffered differential settlement, it was uncommon for the sidewalls to break. I am aware of at least (2) facilities built by others, suffered foundation failures resulting in a leaning structure. The article does not state whether the cracked and broken portions were slip walls or the foundation. It would be very helpful to know, if possible what portion of the elevator broke.

Leave a Reply